Editorial policy

Review policy.

Our standards for what gets reviewed, how scores are assigned, and what happens when things change.

01

Platform selection

We review platforms that are publicly available, have an active user base, and offer a meaningful AI companion experience. We do not review platforms that are in closed beta, require invitation-only access, or that we cannot independently test with a paid account.

02

No pay-to-review

Platforms cannot pay to be reviewed, pay to receive a higher score, or pay to be excluded from coverage. We have declined requests from platforms offering payment in exchange for coverage. If a platform approaches us, we note it internally but it does not affect whether or how we review them.

03

Score updates

Scores are updated when: a platform ships a significant product change; reader feedback or our own re-testing reveals a material shift in quality; or 12 months have passed since the last review. Score changes are noted with a revision date on the relevant review card.

04

Negative coverage

We publish negative findings. If a platform has poor cancellation practices, misleading pricing, or a declining conversation quality, that appears in the review. Affiliate relationships do not create immunity from critical coverage.

05

Corrections

If we publish something factually incorrect, we correct it promptly and note the correction on the page. We do not silently edit published content to remove errors. If you believe something we have published is inaccurate, contact us with evidence and we will investigate.

06

Reader submissions

Reader-submitted experiences are moderated before publication. We publish experiences that are specific, plausible, and consistent with our own testing. We do not publish submissions that appear promotional, contain personal contact details, or that we cannot reasonably assess as genuine. Approved submissions are attributed to the name provided by the reader.